Weekly Market Sentiment Report

Share this post

Coalescence Report 1st May - 8th May 2022

coalescence.substack.com

Coalescence Report 1st May - 8th May 2022

The Weekly Coalescence Sentiment Report: 01/05/2022 - 08/05/2022

Sofien Kaabar, CFA
May 1, 2022
1
Share
Share this post

Coalescence Report 1st May - 8th May 2022

coalescence.substack.com

This report covers the weekly market sentiment and positioning and any changes that have occurred which might present interesting configurations on different asset classes with a specific focus on currencies. The below shows the table of contents of the report:

  1. The COT Report

    • Introduction to the COT Report

    • EUR Currency

    • CHF Currency

    • GBP Currency

    • JPY Currency

    • CAD Currency

    • Interesting Cross Ideas

    • Historical Track Record

  2. The Chaos Impact Index

    • Introduction to the Chaos Impact Index

    • EUR Currency

    • CHF Currency

    • GBP Currency

    • JPY Currency

    • CAD Currency

    • S&P500

    • Gold

  3. The White Index

    • Introduction to the White Index

    • S&P500

    • Historical Track Record

  4. Vision

    • Introduction to Vision

    • S&P500

    • Historical Track Record

  5. The VIX

    • Introduction to the VIX

    • S&P500

    • Historical Track Record

  6. The Millennium Forecast

    • Introduction to the Millennium Forecast

    • ISM PMI

    • Historical Track Record

  7. Bitcoin Tactical Sentiment Index

    • Introduction to the Bitcoin Tactical Sentiment Index

    • Bitcoin

    • Historical Track Record

  8. Disclosure

1. The COT Report

As mentioned in the introductory post, the COT report shows the positioning of the market with respect to a few underlying assets and currencies. The COT strategies are as follows:

  • The COT1 strategy uses a normalization technique to detect imminent market shifts while minimizing lag as much as possible.

  • The COT2 strategy uses a statistical technique to detect sentiment extremes that are bound to reverse.

  • The COT3 strategy uses a deceleration filter to detect exhaustion in positioning trends.

  • The COT4 strategy uses a pattern recognition technique to detect imminent reversals in sentiment.

EUR Currency

Signals from the EUR currency can be used to understand the expected directional bias of the USDEUR pair or any other EUR pair.

The following signal chart shows the latest 250 data with the COT1 signals.

Signal chart.

The charts use major proxies versus the USD: EUR is represented by USDEUR, CHF is represented by USDCHF, GBP is represented by USDGBP, JPY is represented by USDJPY, and CAD is represented by USDCAD.

The following signal chart shows the latest 250 data with the COT2 signals.

Signal chart.

Green arrows point to a bullish sentiment signal while red arrows point to a bearish sentiment signal.

The following signal chart shows the latest 250 data with the COT3 signals.

Signal chart.

The following signal chart shows the latest 250 data with the COT4 signals.

Signal chart.
Commentary

The signals on USDEUR are mostly neutral and no directional bias in the horizon.

CHF Currency

Signals from the CHF currency can be used to understand the expected directional bias of the USDCHF pair or any other CHF pair.
The following signal chart shows the latest 250 data with the COT1 signals.

Signal chart.

The blue indicator in the second panel is the representation of positioning (and sentiment) with the barriers at 2 and -2.

The following signal chart shows the latest 250 data with the COT2 signals.

Signal chart.

The following signal chart shows the latest 250 data with the COT3 signals.

Signal chart.

The following signal chart shows the latest 250 data with the COT4 signals.

Signal chart.
Commentary

The signals on USDCHF are mostly neutral with a slight bullish bias from two signals given two weeks ago by COT2 and COT3 which still have upside potential.

GBP Currency

Signals from the GBP currency can be used to understand the expected directional bias of the USDGBP pair or any other GBP pair.
The following signal chart shows the latest 250 data with the COT1 signals.

Signal chart.

The following signal chart shows the latest 250 data with the COT2 signals.

Signal chart.

The following signal chart shows the latest 250 data with the COT3 signals.

Signal chart.

A cluster of signals enhances the conviction.

The following signal chart shows the latest 250 data with the COT4 signals.

Signal chart.
Commentary

The signals on USDGBP are mostly neutral and no directional bias in the horizon.

JPY Currency

Signals from the JPY currency can be used to understand the expected directional bias of the USDJPY pair or any other JPY pair.
The following signal chart shows the latest 250 data with the COT1 signals.

Signal chart.

USDJPY has more signals in the COT1 strategy than the others because its model is slightly different than the others (which are homogeneous).

The following signal chart shows the latest 250 data with the COT2 signals.

Signal chart.

The following signal chart shows the latest 250 data with the COT3 signals.

Signal chart.

It may happen that from time to time, no sentiment signal occurs for a long time.

The following signal chart shows the latest 250 data with the COT4 signals.

Signal chart.
Commentary

The signals on USDJPY are mostly neutral and no directional bias in the horizon.

CAD Currency

Signals from the CAD currency can be used to understand the expected directional bias of the USDCAD pair or any other CAD pair.
The following signal chart shows the latest 250 data with the COT1 signals.

Signal chart.

The following signal chart shows the latest 250 data with the COT2 signals.

Signal chart.

The following signal chart shows the latest 250 data with the COT3 signals.

Signal chart.

Sentiment signals must not be used as trade recommendations or investment solicitations.

The following signal chart shows the latest 250 data with the COT4 signals.

Signal chart.
Commentary

The signals on USDCAD are mostly neutral and no directional bias in the horizon. The last signal was bullish given around the last local bottom but it has already reached its potential.

Interesting Cross Ideas

A cross is a currency pair without the USD. An example of this would be EURCAD. The interesting part comes with the fact of the double conviction event which is having a bullish signal on the base currency and a bearish signal on the price currency.

There are no interesting cross plays for this week. If an opportunity presents itself, the details would be given in this section.

Historical Track Record

As a reminder, the next table shows the historical non-binding track record of the model using the specific back-testing rules described in the introductory post.

Past results are not representative of future results.

2. The Chaos Impact Index

The Chaos Impact Index is a calculation based on many variables from different areas such as opinions, volatility, momentum, short-term flows, and psychological factors. Its name comes from the fact that it tries to find hidden patterns within the chaos of the elements it is comprised of.

The Chaos Impact Index is calculated on a daily basis but is part of a weekly document and therefore, if a signal occurs during the week, an email and a post would be sent with the market expectations post-signal. The index is presented as a binary event where it shows the market sentiment:

  • Whenever the market sentiment is bullish, the market is shown in green.

  • Whenever the market sentiment is bearish, the market is shown in red.

EUR Currency

The following signal chart shows the latest 250 data with the signals.

Market regime implied by sentiment.
Commentary

The market sentiment appears to be bearish. Market participants are expecting more weakness but the sentiment is overly bearish and hence, it may be risky or a little late for the move to continue lower, this is however a subjective interpretation and the numbers show a market that is expecting more weakness.

CHF Currency

The following signal chart shows the latest 250 data with the signals.

Market regime implied by sentiment.
Commentary

The market sentiment appears to be bearish. Market participants are expecting more weakness.

GBP Currency

The following signal chart shows the latest 250 data with the signals.

Market regime implied by sentiment.
Commentary

The market sentiment appears to be bearish. Market participants are expecting more weakness.

JPY Currency

The following signal chart shows the latest 250 data with the signals.

Market regime implied by sentiment.
Commentary

The market sentiment appears to be overly bearish. Market participants are expecting more weakness however, the extreme bearish sentiment is a double-edged sword as it may imply a full reversal. This is unconfirmed and the observation from this index is that the sentiment is bearish on the JPY (Careful as this implies JPYUSD instead of the usual USDJPY).

CAD Currency

The following signal chart shows the latest 250 data with the signals.

Market regime implied by sentiment.
Commentary

The market sentiment appears to be bullish even though it may be shady as the trend is not quite determined yet. Market participants are expecting more strength or are awaiting further confirmation for a bearish move on the CAD (Careful as this implies CADUSD instead of the usual USDCAD).

S&P500

The following signal chart shows the latest 250 data with the signals.

Market regime implied by sentiment.
Commentary

The market sentiment appears to be bearish even though it may be shady as the trend is not quite determined yet. Market participants are expecting more weakness or correction. The bearish market sentiment on the S&P500 index tends to be extremely early as evidenced by the above chart which is why it may be better to focus on bullish market expectations for better representative signals.

Gold

The following signal chart shows the latest 250 data with the signals.

Market regime implied by sentiment.
Commentary

The market sentiment appears to be bullish even though it may be shady as the trend is not quite determined yet. Market participants are expecting more strength.

3. The White Index

Long-only traders who like to time the dips and follow the upside trend should monitor the White Index as it has been specifically designed for this purpose.

The following signal chart shows the latest 500 data with the signals.

Commentary

At the moment, the White Index is neutral and no signal is given. The White Index is calculated on a daily basis but is part of a weekly document and therefore, if a signal occurs during the week, an email and a post would be sent with the market expectation post-signal.

Historical Track Record

As a reminder, the next table shows the historical non-binding track record of the model using the specific back-testing rules described in the introductory post.

Past results are not representative of future results.

4. Vision

Vision uses insights from dealer markets to find statistical extremes. Rich with information, the indicator seems to outperform its peers in predictability.

The following signal chart shows the latest 500 data with the signals.

Signal chart.
Commentary

Patience is key with Vision as even though its signals are uncommon, they are of high quality. Vision is calculated on a daily basis but is part of a weekly document and therefore, if a signal occurs during the week, an email and a post would be sent with the market expectation post-signal.

Historical Track Record

As a reminder, the next table shows the historical non-binding track record of the model using the specific back-testing rules described in the introductory post.

Past results are not representative of future results.

5. The VIX

The CBOE’s Volatility Index is a continuously updated index that shows the market’s expectations for the strength of short-term changes of the S&P500. Since it is calculated from near-term options on the S&P500, it can be considered as a 30-day projection of future volatility. It is negatively correlated with the S&P500 and therefore, high extreme values are associated with a bottom of the stock market while low extreme values are somewhat associated with a correction on the stock market even though the bearish predictive ability of the VIX is not significant.

The following signal chart shows the latest 500 observations of the inverted VIX (for better interpretability) with the signals.

Signal chart.
Commentary

The divergence signals on the VIX are not very common and are better in a bullish market even though bearish divergence signals may point to a correction or a stabilization phase. At the moment, no signals are present.

Historical Track Record

As a reminder, the next table shows the historical non-binding track record of the model using the specific back-testing rules described in the introductory post.

Past results are not representative of future results.

6. The Millennium Forecast

During the introductory post, you must have understood that the Millennium Forecast targets the long-term as opposed to other indicators.

The following Figure shows a window of the last number of observations of the ISM PMI with the signals generated by the Millennium Forecast. Refer to the commentary below to understand what to expect.

ISM PMI with the Millennium Forecast model.
ISM PMI with the Millennium Forecast model.

Remember that the two outputs of the Millennium Forecast are as follows:

  • Expansion: This label represents an economic non-linear expansion.

  • Contraction: This label represents an economic non-linear contraction.

Commentary

The Millennium Forecast is neutral at the moment with the last signal given in February 2020 for an expansion signal that at the moment has not yet been reversed which means that the algorithm does not forecast a contraction for the moment but also is not so keen on an expansion either.

However, given the current global circumstances, a fast (more reactive) algorithm has been applied which shows that a contraction signal has been given around the top in February 2021 with the previous expansion signal given at the same time as the standard algorithm which is February 2020. The hit ratio of the fast algorithm is 70.96% compared to 74.07% for the standard algorithm.

To summarize, the current state is tilted towards a contracting environment and the next expansion signal is unlikely to occur before at least 5-6 months.

Historical Track Record

As a reminder, the next table shows the historical non-binding track record of the model using the specific back-testing rules described in the introductory post.

Past results are not representative of future results.

7. Bitcoin Tactical Sentiment Index

The Bitcoin Tactical Sentiment Index is a daily sentiment-based indicator which uses insights from volatility, direct surveys, open interest, and patterns to calculate a normalized value that shows where the inflection points are likely to be.

The following signal chart shows the latest 500 observations with the signals.

Signal chart.
Commentary

The Bitcoin Tactical Sentiment Index is neutral at the moment with the last signal given in Late January 2022 for an expected 5-day bullish move which showed to last even more.

The index is closer to a bullish signal that to a bearish signal at the moment but nothing is confirmed yet. As it is calculated on a daily basis, if a trigger occurs, an instant update would be sent in the form of a brief post detailing what to expect.

Historical Track Record

As a reminder, the next table shows the historical non-binding track record of the model using the specific back-testing rules described in the introductory post.

Past results are not representative of future results.

8. Disclosure

Every information contained in the report is solely for the purpose of showing another angle. Since it is not investment advice nor a trade recommendation, you must not use the conclusion of the report as the sole reason for your trading and investing activities. Make sure you know how to include the above elements in your trading framework in a way that does not change your methodology.

Data can have many representations and the information presented is but one side which may be incomplete. All back-testing and forward testing results reflect their own time period and not the future.

The information contained in the report are proprietary and only you must use it. If you have to share it, please state the source correctly by referring the page of Coalescence.

1
Share
Share this post

Coalescence Report 1st May - 8th May 2022

coalescence.substack.com
Comments
Top
New
Community

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 Sofien Kaabar
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing